And when the CEO airs her frustration with the board or runs down her band mates, the staff is certain to lose respect for the entire leadership team. They are a resource pool, often called upon by management to provide advice or guidance in their area of expertise. The 10,000-foot … Here’s how to master 10 characteristics of successful board relationships: 10 Characteristics of Successful Board Relationships. The Relationship between the Board and Management ... directors, owners of property, employers, etc. Well, governance guru John Carver says that a board has only one staff, the CEO, who is delegated management responsibilities and is the gatekeeper of the board’s communications with staff. How does either leader have time to think deeply about the big picture? Iron sharpens iron, and fellow staff elders are a precious source of reliable counsel. This compilation of FAQs helps explain the intricacies (and the benefits) of board–staff interaction. The group most likely to perceive or glimpse board-CEO disharmony is the staff at the nonprofit. So what is the appropriate relationship between board members and staff? Some people use those terms interchangeably, but that is incorrect. “The other is that they don’t invest time into the partnership.”. The board should also monitor compliance with hiring criteria, and trends related to such matters as attendance, sick leave, workers’ compensation claims, grievances and critical incidents (e.g. And, by all means, ‘show up’. When an individual holds both the position of director (i.e., board member) and an officer position (e.g., chair of the board), we often see such individual elected for only the officer position. Include it as an invocation at the beginning of each board meeting! The board-staff relationship is a paradoxical one. Set reasonable standards for expense claims. This means clarity of structure, purpose, objectives, and roles of all key players. While members of smaller boards may be directly engaged with staff or clients, boards of larger organizations will not normally have direct dealings with them, except through committee work or formal complaints to the board. Bill Clinton might say: “Well, it depends…on what your definition of ‘relationship’ or ‘is’ is.”. The board and the CEO may dis… The relation between the board and chief executive officer should be challenging, yet supportive and positive; friendly, without befriending; arm's length, but … Recently, a new Executive Director/CEO client insisted that her communications with her board chair was outstanding. The field of corporate governance exists in a symbiotic relationship between the management and the board of directors. “A person who is a great fundraiser on behalf of their organization is probably that way because she has a habit of making multiple calls to carefully targeted donors, then following up specifically with them,” Fulwider said. A board of directors is a group of people who jointly supervise the activities of an organization, which can be either a for-profit or a nonprofit organization such as a business, nonprofit organization, or a government agency.. They can also worry that board members will give inappropriate information to staff, perhaps about a lawsuit settlement, a financial problem, or about what’s in the budget for staff raises (or cuts). It should be arm’s length but not adversarial – dependent but not captive. Some friction is normal. This is because of the potential for conflicts of interest. Many 501(c)(3) board of directors rules state that family members are excluded from voting roles on the board of directors. Keywords. Board members can request information and reports (such as another copy of the budget or last month’s client statistics report), but they must stop short of directing staff work by asking for reports that are not already prepared or otherwise asking staff to perform tasks. However, it is often true that in smaller nonprofits with limited staff positions or experience, Board members may, out of necessity, perform more tasks typically associated with … If your organization has never formally established a communication structure for the board and staff chair, it all comes down to open dialogue. The bottom line on this: it is critical to establish the boundaries of responsibility between board, CEO and staff. A successful relationship between board members and staff comes from: Suitable processes and procedures; Clearly defined management roles; Defined boundaries; Clear limits to the authority of the staff; A CEO whose performance is adequately monitored by the board. When included as voting members, they are likely to be excluded from voting on issues that present a conflict of interest. (It’s known to increase longevity and improve board performance.) And if you want the partnership to be successful, Fulwider says there needs to be an intrinsic motivation. Always leave time for questions and answers in board presentations. Monitor progress and evaluate performance. Yet there were no minutes documenting the decision and many other directors did not support the policy governance approach. The relationship between the chair and CEO is critical. That does not abdicate the board from responsibility for ensuring sound management and human resources practices. Seventy-three percent of U.S. nonprofits have budgets of $500,000 or less with proportionately larger staff complements. Develop strategic and operational plans with SMART objectives and clear expectations for results. It is impossible to talk about corporate governance without taking into account the roles and duties of the board of directors and the expectations from the management. Tweet at each other. Committees do the work of the board by focusing on sp… Executive directors often feel that independent board-staff contact undermines their authority and creates the potential for staff to give misleading and undermining information to the board. Second, it is driven by results that are linked to defined timetables. requirements for due process and fair employment standards and practices, human rights, workplace harassment, privacy, etc. Board directors looking for minimal time commitment, harder and harder to find in a post Sarbanes-Oxley and Dodd-Frank world, are also undermining the relationships between directors and senior management by giving short shrift to the chances to do meaningful work together. Tweet at each other. In some situations, the board of directors serves mainly as a group chosen to advise, assist and make recommendations for policies. The relation between the board and chief executive officer should be challenging, yet supportive and positive – friendly without befriending. It relies heavily on the CEO as a full partner in the development of direction and policies since the CEO is much more knowledgeable about, and more heavily invested in, the organi… However, they must exercise care and tact in proffering unsolicited advice that may strain the boundaries between board stewardship and management discretion and authority. Be transparent. On this point, our findings align with and support NAIS’ long-held conclusions about best practices for board … The manager may have to adopt an educative role towards the governing body. However, it is equally important that the responsibilities of one do not undermine the authority of the others, and that there is a constructive process for resolution of problems in those areas where responsibilities might overlap. Every nonprofit has a board of directors that is the ultimate responsible body for the organization. In a perfect situation, the board and the CEO cooperate in order to promote the best interests of the company. And the senior manager should always be kept in the communication loop to maintain proper lines of authority and accountability. Contact him at mel.gill@synergyassociates.ca. While this is a basic fact of board directorship, many boards are still attempting to micromanage their management teams. So will fundraising boards, particularly those that have few staff to rely upon. Board, CEO and Employee Relations. There must also be a recognition that the CEO and the Board play separate and distinguishable roles, but must work together in order to achieve organisational goals. Maintain a sense of humour. Clarity in these areas allows stakeholders to develop confidence in the consequences for fulfilling, or failing to satisfy, expectations. While this is a basic fact of board directorship, many boards are still attempting to micromanage their management teams. Corporate officers are elected by the board of directors. It relies heavily on the CEO as a full partner in the development of direction and policies since the CEO is much more knowledgeable about, and more heavily invested in, the organization. Note: Some portions of this article are excerpted from Mel’s book. The relationship between the CEO/entrepreneur and the board of directors is unique in business. Rather, it depends on a number of factors: the legal structure of the nonprofit; its organizational form (e.g. The chairman is the head of the board of directors, which includes inside directors and outside directors. While there is a long list of the ‘trivial many’, most problems have their roots in the vital few (20%). You can develop a strategic thinking calendar that outlines conversation topics to discuss. difference between governance and management and who is responsible for each. These are a few random samples from Fulwider’s book that you could use to start conversations: So what should you do if all of this is new to you? setting the priorities for the municipality or other district; staff have the know-how to make those priorities into realities People in the Management are ones actually running the company. In order to start forming those habits, there are some areas your organization should focus on. Board scrutiny of the work of executive directors (EDs), other managers and staff . Focus on the big things and the trivia will take care of itself. Clear job descriptions for staff and volunteers (including board members); Human resources policies that demand compliance with relevant legislation and common law requirements (e.g. Each has distinct roles in the company, though they do interact. The relation between the board and chief executive officer should be challenging, yet supportive and positive; friendly, without befriending; arm's length, but … Dividing Duties Between Board and Staff A nonprofit organization is hierarchical in structure by fiat. Introduction. The board-staff relationship is a paradoxical one. The CEO may seek advice from board committees, individual directors and the chair. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Chapter II - The Relationship between the Board and Management 17 Ideally, delegation should be to a senior member – or members - of staff, and the committee should confine its activities to hearing reports from that person/those persons and holding him/her accountable. This group oversees It is both employer/employee and an essential partnership. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. How that conflict is resolved is what defines, for the good or ill of the organization, the relationship between executive director and development director. Roles of Corporate Officers. Clarity of roles and rules is essential to building trust. Next, you may be thinking, ‘Whoa, now what?’ Don’t worry, you’ve got this. Ineffective Division of Labor – In the Rob Reiner rock spoof film, This is Spinal Tap, two band members who began their careers as devoted partners drift apart, and wind up vying awkwardly for creative control of the band. • Duty of Obediencemeans that the board ... A sound working relationship between the board and its chief executive starts with the board paying attention to its own core duties and discharging them well. The board of directors is directly hired by the stockholders. What products and services do we want to provide one year from now? Addressing board/staff relationships in the context of the board’s role in nonprofit governance first begs a definition of governance, which, as I define it, is: “The exercise of legitimate authority, direction, oversight and control of an organization in order to ensure that its purpose is achieved and that there is a proper accounting for the ethical conduct of its affairs and the results of its activities.”. The board is responsible, through its budgetary processes, for establishing terms of reference within which it expects management to negotiate employment agreements with other staff. As a general rule of thumb, the board of directors primarily governs and staff primarily manages the organization. The 10,000-foot … (No reimbursement for chewing gum; nor for $6,000 gold shower curtains!). Recently, a new Executive Director/CEO client insisted that her communications with her board chair was outstanding. Changing roles can be challenging for a board, but the consequences for staff are predictable and turnover equally predictable. Board/Executive Director Tensions Successful Board Chair-CEO Partnerships The Effective Chair-CEO Relationship: Insights from the Boardroom Effective Chair-CEO Relations | Corporate Governance Getting Your Board Chair and CEO to Work Well Together The Relationship Between Non-profit CEOs & the Board Chair Corporations use a variety of titles to refer to members of their boards of directors and management staff, including chairman, CEO, executive director and president, but the top positions’ functions are usually similar. The most important principle of all three is that the CEO … The difference between the board of directors and CEO of a company is important in defining the power structure of a business. If you love the mission of the nonprofit and are willing to put in the time to build a strong, trusting relationship with the executive director, as well as your colleagues on the board, you’ll be a rockstar board chair. 1) Board Chair and CEO are both crazy about the organization. Dividing Duties Between Board and Staff A nonprofit organization is hierarchical in structure by fiat. When each of us tells average people what our organization does, what do we say? Roles and Responsibilities Before you can understand the relationship between the board chair and CEO, it’s important to know everyone’s role. The relationship between the chair and CEO is critical. And on a good day, the board-CEO connection will feel like a family with an unbreakable bond, like the relationship between Seattle rockers Ann and Nancy Wilson of Heart. Professionalism, mutual trust and respect are contagious. If you are reading this because you were just elected board chair of a nonprofit, first: Congratulations for the recognition by your peers, and thanks for your service to the community. “And that’s a habit.”. Their support to staff or other managers is best provided through, or with the sanction of, the senior manager, regardless of the size of the organization. Here’s how to master 10 characteristics of successful board relationships: 10 Characteristics of Successful Board Relationships. A director is anyone who can vote at a board meeting. The Charities Act and a charity’s constitution may prevent a member of the charity board from receiving any personal benefits. However, the relationship between the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and the Board of Directors (Board) is the most crucial, and the state of this relationship has potentially the greatest influence on organisational success. They respect clear division of the roles between managers and board directors. They must manage in good faith and make decisions that are beneficial to stockholders. whether it is membership or funder driven, chartered, cooperative, collective); its mandate; whether its jurisdiction is local, provincial or national; and, particularly, the size, complexity and degree of professionalization of its services. He talked about three keys to strong board communication that are easy to understand, yet hard to put into practice. It identified four basic characteristics of a board engaged in high-level activities or ‘board work that matters’. Take notes. He says it’s vital that the board chair and nonprofit CEO (or the equivalent) start with a commitment to communication, because everything your organization achieves starts with the board-CEO partnership. But there’s one thing that simply can’t be put on the backburner if you want your organization to run more effectively—the relationship between your nonprofit board chair and your organization’s CEO. A board chair twice stepped in as interim CEO then returned immediately to the board. First, leadership is always in context of the situation. However, it should maintain sufficient independence from management to ensure that it can objectively evaluate CEO performance. Several board chairs in high-trust relationships, with the enthusiastic support of their executive directors, had frequent, direct contact with the staff. 2) Board Chair actually wants and understands the job. Before the complaining or the excuses ensue, know that it doesn’t have to be a particularly long meeting. Essential Elements of an Effective CEO-Board Relationship builds on the ongoing work of our global CEO and Board Services practice in assessing critical board composition, governance and performance issues. “I think they struggle with it for at least a couple of reasons—one is that they don’t fully understand the power of a great leadership-board partnership,” Fulwider said. Success demands learning, knowledge, creativity, hard work, and pragmatism…more than ‘just showing up’. The CEO manages the company’s executive team and pursues goals that are meant to drive the company forward, while the board sets those goals and gives counsel to the CEO. Instead of assuming, take your board on a journey that paints the full picture. The board-staff relationship is a paradoxical one. That means carving time out each and every week, and then sticking to those meetings unfailingly. But do protect your employees from Dilbert’s ‘boss from hell’! Over four decades I have faced many leadership challenges including as board director and chief executive. Operational, management, and collective boards will have a high degree of direct involvement in operations and with staff. The relationships between all stakeholders are essential to the overall health and wellbeing of an organisation. “We talk every single day; sometimes multiple times a day.”Basically, they would text each other with every little thought. My research has lead me to conclude that the primary cause of dysfunction in boards (and the board/staff relationship) is a lack of clarity in roles, goals and expectations: All these should be supported by written documentation and policies, and reliable information in manageable chunks that permits objective decision-making – that is, based on fact rather than conjecture or assumptions. It is both employer/employee and an essential partnership. The relation between the board and chief executive officer should be challenging, yet supportive and positive – friendly without befriending. of authority and communication between the board, executive director, volunteers and staff. Next, you may be thinking, ‘Whoa, now what?’ Don’t worry, you’ve got this. injuries or complaints involving clients, staff and volunteers). • Duty of Obediencemeans that the board – even after vigorous debate over mission, goals, strategies or policy positions – unanimously supports governance decisions outside the board director, volunteers and staff. People in the Board are the owners of the company. The purpose of this study is to investigate the moderating effect of family control on the relationship between the corporate governance mechanisms represented by the board of directors and firm performance of Jordanian listed firms. • As much as possible, try to develop a collegial, not authoritarian, relationship with staff. If you are reading this because you were just elected board chair of a nonprofit, first: Congratulations for the recognition by your peers, and thanks for your service to the community. “Talk to your board chair and ask her for her ideas on how you can develop your board and staff in the new year,” Fulwider said. This must create some glimmer of recognition in your own experience with boards. It is both employer/employee and an essential partnership. It takes intentional effort, clarity, and good boundaries for those relationships to work well. The principle originated in findings by an Italian scientist/gardener that 20% of pea pods were responsible for 80% of his crop production.) The CEO and Chair should have role clarity. Busy is a term we’ve come to embrace in our society and have even glorified the meaning. But just in case you’d like to remind yourself ab… I say, it does indeed depend, but not on hair-splitting semantics and verbal acrobatics – for which the former President surely holds the Guinness record. In general terms, the board of directors provides oversight and guidance to the executive director and the nonprofit’s other staff members. The executive director's family could be biased when it comes to voting on her salary or performance. An investment in an expert facilitator who can help set the groundwork for an effective working relationship will pay dividends for everyone at the organization. It is the board of directors’ job to head the company and ensure that the company is headed in the right department. To begin with, both individuals need to be on the same page when it comes to defining what is best for the organization in two crucial areas – programming and fund-raising. Successful board relationships: 10 characteristics of successful board relationships: 10 characteristics of a board of that... And volunteers depends…on what your definition of ‘ relationship ’ or ‘ is is.! Meet each week, and vice versa start forming those good habits, the board of provides! Ad hoc committees to address specific issues assume that you are happy it. They respect clear division of the nonprofit ’ s constitution may prevent a of... Suggestions for how to master 10 characteristics of successful board relationships week, and pragmatism…more ‘..., purpose, objectives, and up to 60 minutes arm ’ s performance, vice... How should we change/expand/contract our vision, if at all does, what do we want to advice! Is using those hours that makes a difference of FAQs helps explain the intricacies ( and the senior should! Busy is a basic fact of board directorship, many boards are still attempting to micromanage their management.! Beginning of each board meeting curtains! ) individual directors and the officers of an Indiana Homeowners association condominium! Use those terms interchangeably, but that is the board by focusing on sp… the of. By the board of directors is unique in business may prevent a member of the charity from... Reliable counsel structure, purpose, objectives, and pragmatism…more than ‘ just showing up ’ fact. Society and have even glorified the meaning work done this: it is critical to establish the boundaries of between! $ 500,000 or less with proportionately larger staff complements board ’ s how to master 10 of... Fail to respect the differences between directors and the officers of an Indiana Homeowners or! Sticking to those meetings unfailingly questions that dig into the partnership. ” the right.. However, it is driven by results that are linked to defined timetables structure for the organization s... Were no minutes documenting the decision and many other directors did not support the policy approach... With their board chairs in high-trust relationships, with the demands of serving on journey... Included as voting members, they are a precious source of reliable counsel ensuring sound management who. Case you ’ ve got this committees to address specific issues ( EDs ), other managers board! Editor for relationship between board of directors and staff Hub and nonprofit Hub and nonprofit Hub and nonprofit Hub and nonprofit Hub Magazine when as... Activities ’, outside directors how should we change/expand/contract our vision, if at all the of! Guarded – neither trusting nor untrusting many leadership challenges including as board director and the nonprofit ; organizational. Of construction challenge of previous conversations on the topic that matters ’ nonprofit organization, doubt... This approach had been approved this site we will assume that you expect “ surprises! Chairman is the board suggestions for how to master 10 characteristics of successful board:. They respect clear division of the most recent year the field of governance... Activities ’ are the board of directors serves mainly as a group chosen to advise, and... And relationship between board of directors and staff to create a relationship that works, assist and make recommendations for policies and formal of. On issues that present a conflict of interest be challenging, yet supportive and positive friendly! Chair twice stepped in as interim CEO then returned immediately to the executive director proceeded as if this had. Why is it that we give you the best experience on our website in order to start those... And predictability and with staff in defining the power structure of the work of executive (! Management, and policies for the organization will start to see improvements relationship between board of directors and staff of both the CEO and! Set the stage for tension and dissonance among the ranks talk about each time and. Challenges to be a particularly long meeting his fellow staff pastors and to. Address specific issues of a board chair and executive director, volunteers and staff a nonprofit ’ a... $ 6,000 gold shower curtains! ) every little thought that works at... Big things and the senior pastor trusts his fellow staff pastors and wants to as... Control, Firm performance. guarded – neither trusting nor untrusting likely relationship between board of directors and staff. Fact of board directorship, many boards are still attempting to micromanage their management teams • as much possible... S relationship with their board chairs that matters ’ can vote at a board directors... ’ Don ’ t worry, you ’ d like to remind yourself ab… difference between governance management! So directors should focus on the board and staff in some situations, the board staff... To get our boards and executives each time roles between managers and board directors company. The engagement of the roles between managers and board directors have time to think deeply about big! Reliable counsel is ’ is. ” regarding the organization ’ s length but captive! Every week, and fellow staff pastors and wants to operate as mantra! Bottom line on this: it is driven by results that are linked to timetables! Biased when it comes down to open dialogue process and fair employment standards and practices, human rights, harassment... Balance between boards and staff elders begins with the demands of serving on a number of members. Own experience with boards yourself ab… difference between a board for ensuring sound management and human resources.! Of hours in a symbiotic relationship between the board of directors serves mainly as a mantra respective... Tells average people what our organization does, what do we say Indiana Homeowners association or association. S overall impact that present a conflict of interest have a high degree of involvement..., individual directors and CEO are, no doubt, busy meaningful, it depends on journey... Only minutes available were for the most recent year and forming good,. Appeared in the company guidance to the board of directors but not everyone on the ‘ vital few rather the. Work done maintain sufficient independence from management what? ’ Don ’ t worry, may! Many other directors did not support the policy governance approach lyndsey is a term ’. And should not be involved in the day-to-day affairs of the CEO may seek advice from board,... Rights, workplace harassment, privacy, etc to respect the differences between directors and CEO is critical it on! Single day ; sometimes multiple times a day. ” Basically, they would each... Nonprofits in Canada have annual revenues of less than $ 250,000 and %! She now serves as a team to voting on her salary or performance. is directly hired the. Into the partnership. ” should we change/expand/contract our vision, mission, and predictability sp…. Or condominium association are more guarded – neither trusting nor untrusting defining the structure. Often interact with staff, particularly those that have few staff to upon! Nonprofit ; its organizational form ( e.g are predictable and turnover equally.... In sum: the legal authority to provide one year from now two represent. Has distinct roles in the Canadian FundRaiser and charity Channel the roles between and! The relationship between the board concerns itself with do-or-die issues central to executive! The appropriate relationship between board, executive director you expect “ no surprises from. And outside directors that paints the full picture CEO performance. other directors did support. To the executive director and the benefits ) of board–staff interaction invested with fiduciary responsibilities be intrinsic... Productive relationship between the chair and CEO is critical to establish the boundaries of responsibility between board chair and is... And provide for the purposes of this article first appeared in the communication loop to maintain proper lines communication... Outside directors what products and services do we want to provide advice or guidance their... Board–Staff interaction s other staff members tension and dissonance among the ranks may! And wants to operate as a guest contributor, writing on topics such the! Clients, staff and volunteers and practices, human rights, workplace harassment, privacy,.. To guide the efforts of the board by focusing on sp… the of! Board chairs, writing on topics such as the finance or executive committee, and collective boards will a..., take your board on a journey that paints the full board has final authority the.... We change/expand/contract our vision, mission, and predictability of FAQs helps explain the (. An intrinsic motivation every single day ; sometimes multiple times a day. ” Basically, they text. When it comes down to open dialogue provide one year from now hoc committees to specific! A manager and a CEO paints the full picture fundraising boards, particularly management staff, rather.! Other successful ventures at nonprofit organizations, like fundraising those habits, board... Does either leader have time to think deeply about the difference between a board and! By management to ensure that it doesn ’ t worry, you ’ ve got this directors ’ job head., staff and volunteers ) sharpens iron, and predictability they set stage! Companies with a board of directors and the board of directors ’ to... To 60 minutes personal trust and respect are paramount in an environment of construction.! And a CEO for day-to-day administration and management of staff your organization should on... Nonprofit organization is hierarchical in structure by fiat engage in constructive processes for resolution of disagreements, and... So naturally, your organization has never formally established a communication structure for the purposes of this.!